Which girl looks the best overall

[Rocky]

Vanessa Vs Egypt

[eclectic_co]

I have always liked the way that Vanessa works the camera! She is terrific on film. I would like to meet her in person sometime.

:cool:


Vanessa Vs Egypt

[cumshooter69]

Both are very nice but I'm going with Vanessa

[nycguy]

Gotta go wit Vanessa on this one. Interesting thread, I hope no one takes offense.

[DrDickenstein]

Vanessa. Somebody set up some brackets for....Tranny Madness!!! :D

[phi0820]

Vanessa...for the curves, plus of the two she seems more capable of whooping my ass if she found out I voted against her. I'm not trying have my skinny ass on Youtube under "man gets smacked up by tranny."

Nah, definitely Vanessa.

[bigdicki]

My girl Vanessa aka Reina for sure. But Egypt is a cutie too.

[ty-clone]

egypt got pure natural beauty

them pics were taken a year ago when she just 1st started to transform, love to see her now

[eclectic_co]

Would be nice to compare photos from a similar time frame in transition if we are going to go down this path. My previous comments were strictly on the photo quality and not the looks of the ladies. Both ladies are quite beautiful... Hell that is why they were picked... YES?

:cool:


egypt got pure natural beauty

them pics were taken a year ago when she just 1st started to transform, love to see her now

[GroobySteven]

I'm not a fan of this "compare" or competition ... and I haven't been a fan of Rocky's posts, some of which I've had to delete.

This isn't the ethos of this site Rocky. You've put up two VERY different looking models and asked us to compare. I question your rationale, your class and your reasoning for doing this.
You're on a warning.

[Ms Remy M]

I'm not a fan of this "compare" or competition ... and I haven't been a fan of Rocky's posts, some of which I've had to delete.

This isn't the ethos of this site Rocky. You've put up two VERY different looking models and asked us to compare. I question your rationale, your class and your reasoning for doing this.
You're on a warning.

?
I've questioned his topics as well, but competition is built into the site (i.e. voting top 50 models, tranny awards) so as long as light hearted it seems innocent enough.

I had a hard time choosing but went with Egypt, her look kind of reminds me of college chic over here at HU. I do agree the comparison choices should be chosen a bit more carefully perhaps, this was like comparing Cognac and Scotch (I like both but for different reasons).

[Nassau]

I'm not a fan of this "compare" or competition ... and I haven't been a fan of Rocky's posts, some of which I've had to delete.

This isn't the ethos of this site Rocky. You've put up two VERY different looking models and asked us to compare. I question your rationale, your class and your reasoning for doing this.
You're on a warning.

I kno the guy and i can say he didn't mean but he does come off as a dickhead some time lol but as for the question I gotta go with egypt on this one

[Nassau]

I'm not a fan of this "compare" or competition ... and I haven't been a fan of Rocky's posts, some of which I've had to delete.

This isn't the ethos of this site Rocky. You've put up two VERY different looking models and asked us to compare. I question your rationale, your class and your reasoning for doing this.
You're on a warning.
Wouldn't it be kind of silly comparing 2 similar girls

[bigdicki]

I'm not a fan of this "compare" or competition ... and I haven't been a fan of Rocky's posts, some of which I've had to delete.

This isn't the ethos of this site Rocky. You've put up two VERY different looking models and asked us to compare. I question your rationale, your class and your reasoning for doing this.
You're on a warning.

Come on old boy get the pinecone out your arse! :p

Some of Rocky's posts (e.g. the whats wrong with her dick post) seem a bit juvenile and low-class, but this one is similar to several other posts that were made in the past. Like Remy said, competition is built into the site with the Top 50 and girl of the week. Criticize him for his truly bad behaviour not all of it. ;)

[kilakali]

Its even more silly comparing 2 girls in different stages of transition. Thats why i didnt vote. Its not fair compairing a girl who just started transitioning to one who has completely transitioned. Breast vs. No Breast, Facial Feminization vs. No Facial Feminization. The thread stated best overall thats why im using these examples.

To comment on top 50 its All Time Favorites, not who is the best looking or biggest ass, etc.

Wouldn't it be kind of silly comparing 2 similar girls

[twowaybro]

EGYPT....even in these photos that show her early in her transition....requested an update of her a while back....would love to see how she has progressed.

[phi0820]

I disagree with the "2 stages in transition" complaints. There are numerous cases of alterations actually taking away from a girl's appearance and Egypt is beautiful; in a poll of who looks better *overall*, I don't think she's coming in with any kind of handicap. And other than the number of girls involved in the competition, this isn't much different from the Top 50 Favorites.

I am kinda bothered by the singling out of two girls like this, especially knowing some of the girls do check the board, but even then modeling for the site does kinda invite that sort of thing.

[bigdicki]

Its even more silly comparing 2 girls in different stages of transition. Thats why i didnt vote. Its not fair compairing a girl who just started transitioning to one who has completely transitioned. Breast vs. No Breast, Facial Feminization vs. No Facial Feminization. The thread stated best overall thats why im using these examples.

To comment on top 50 its All Time Favorites, not who is the best looking or biggest ass, etc.

And so "all time favorites" has nothing to do with how they look? :rolleyes:

[GroobySteven]

This is completely different from the Top 50, which is based on votes and serves to let us know the most popular girls.
By picking two models, both with completely different looks and stage of transition, then by proxy, he is soliciting for bad opinions of one of the models.

If he wishes to know if guys prefer the more voluptuous models further down the round like Vanessa, or a more waif-like, earlier transition, like Egypt ... then that should have been the question, with non-commital examples.

This sort of ill-spirited or poorly thought-out question does nothing to help us get new models, who often visit these pages, to come and work for us, if they're going to be put out for potential ridicule.
Thankfully most of the members show more tact and class, than others.

[kilakali]

C'mon BD we all know some of the top 50 is not based on looks. We have a large number of cockhounds and ass men as members look at some of the comments left on the profiles. You see some are only commented on size not looks.
And so "all time favorites" has nothing to do with how they look? :rolleyes:

[DrDickenstein]

Don't see a problem with these little pick'em postings. Regardless of transition stage, body type, etc....ppl are going to have different preferences no matter what. The problem is that too many folks will go negative on the model they don't choose instead of highlighting why they like what they like. And this could be potentially bad for business, as Seanchai says.

As for the Top 50, I also see it as being very similar. I just ran a quick scroll. Well over half the Top 50 are big dick models. Since there's a minimum # of votes required....it's clear big dicks get the votes and are most popular all-time whatever as voted by more members. It's a porn site, not a beauty contest. Even if it was the "Top 50 Most Beautiful/Passable"....beauty varies from one viewer to the next.

A model gets 5 stars from me for alot of different reasons and I'm sure it's the same for everybody else. Body, dick, titties, ASS, looks, eyes, lips, performance in the vid.... Any one or more looks good/great/amazing to me, then....click!! Just another 2 cents.

[TSSexyChanel]

i co sign what sean said but yall should already know that would be my reply

sayin you love and respect transexual women yet turn around in the same breath and objectify and insult them is a real contridition

we already as transwomen dont get along and these competitions that men are always trying to get us off into only fuels the fire of a problem that has our community going no where fast.

[TSSexyChanel]

also not every girl is blessed with the self esteem I have some of them actually care what other people think of them. How do you think the girls that come up on the loosing end of these little contest feel like?

[kilakali]

Both comments well stated Chanel.

[bigdicki]

also not every girl is blessed with the self esteem I have some of them actually care what other people think of them. How do you think the girls that come up on the loosing end of these little contest feel like?

I see your point but BOTH girls were being given huge props for their beauty. I don't think anyone said anything negative about either; hell, how could you as they are both beautiful. There is no "loser" in this "contest" because they are both beautiful.

Now on the objectification point, yes we are objectifying to some degree. I would say most of the dudes on this forum also seem to respect the girls. Yes, there are some assholes or some generally ok dudes who make some stupid ass post from time to time (may be me :rolleyes:) but most show respect. I would say the objectification here is no worse or no better than ogling Vic's Secrets catalog or Playboy or "mainstream" porn. Its all in fun and in celebration of the beauty and sexuality of the tg. Now, with that said, show me some ass and titties! :p Just kidding... unless you are about to show me. :cool: