Was The Miss Universe Pageant Wrong for Denying Transwomen?

[Unisex]

Miss Universe Pageant Ousts Transgender Contestant

Posted on: 2:39 pm, March 30, 2012, by Staff Writer



31


Pinterest


0


Share


32


Twitter


1


Email


(CNN) – A Canadian beauty pageant contestant who was disqualified when the Miss Universe Canada organizers discovered she was transgender is not ready to speak to reporters, a representative for the 6 foot-1-inch tall blonde model said Tuesday.

Jenna Talackova was one of the 65 finalists selected to contend for the title of Miss Universe Canada and the honor of representing her country in the Miss Universe competition, but she will not be allowed to compete because organizers say Talackova lied about having undergone sexual reassignment surgery and did not meet requirements for the pageant.

“As with any competition, the Miss Universe pageant has rules which apply to all of its franchises around the world. Such rules include, but are not limited to, citizenship, age, and marital status requirements. Additionally, the rules currently state that all contestants must be naturally born females,” the Miss Universe Organization said.

Those rules are not mentioned on the Miss Universe website.

Rory Richards, a spokeswoman for the 23-year-old Vancouver resident, said Talackova will not be able to talk to reporters pending possible legal action.

“Jenna is overwhelmed, and deeply moved, by the support she has received from around the globe, but especially from fellow Canadians that have said how proud they would be if she represented Canada in the Miss Universe pageant,” Richards wrote in an e-mail to CNN on Tuesday.

Before falling out of the public eye, Talackova took to the social networking site Twitter, implying she felt the actions of Miss Universe were the result of prejudice.

“I’m not going to just let them disqualify me over discrimination,” she tweeted, “”I’m not giving up.”

Michael Cole-Schwartz, spokesman for the LGBT advocacy group Human Rights Campaign, called the decision unfair and unnecessary. “Jenna is a woman,” he said. “She presents as a woman, she lives as a woman, and that’s all that matters.”

“Any term that separates her from any other woman is demeaning,” he continued.

He isn’t alone in his support for Talackova. The Facebook page of Miss Universe Canada is full of comments rebuking the pageant’s decision.

“Perhaps you’re unaware that the Ontario Human Rights Code prohibits discrimination based on gender identity,” wrote one Facebook user. “If your requirement is that only women who were born in the right body can compete, then you should probably change the requirements,” posted another.

The controversy has prompted a petition on the social change website Chang.org, which has nearly 32,000 signatures. The petition prompts Beauties of Canada, the company that runs Miss Universe Canada, and Donald Trump, who owns the Miss Universe competition, to reverse the decision.

In a 2010 interview in Thailand, where she was competing for Miss International Queen, a competition for transgender women, Talachova said she knew she was a girl at age 4. She said she started hormone therapy at age 14 and underwent sexual reassignment surgery at 19.

By Chris Boyette

CNN © 2012 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

http://kplr11.com/2012/03/30/miss-un...er-contestant/

[Ms Remy M]

http://kplr11.com/2012/03/30/miss-un...er-contestant/

I read this article the other day. Kind of fucked up, especially considering how beautiful she is. Hopefully with time the will change their rules to allow for trans women. The first time it happens, they'll consider it a 'give me', and wont sweat it too much. I suspect Genetic Females will create a suicide pact after the 2nd trans woman beats them.

[Indy24]

Said this before and I'll say it again....

Because the rules of most pageants require women to look like skinny 12yr old boys with long hair. Having a TS star in one would be an unfair advantage in their eyes.

Yet I'm sure there were plenty of genetic women in that pageant who looked more the part of skinny boy than Ms. Jenna here does so she would've lost anyway.

Get the picture?

[tsamberskyi]

Said this before and I'll say it again....

Because the rules of most pageants require women to look like skinny 12yr old boys with long hair. Having a TS star in one would be an unfair advantage in their eyes.

Yet I'm sure there were plenty of genetic women in that pageant who looked more the part of skinny boy than Ms. Jenna here does so she would've lost anyway.

Get the picture?

No.....there's have been a few sports that are allowing Trans women to compete with genetic women so why not pageants.
Since there is no cosmetic surgery ban what unfair advantage does she really have??

[DYNACORD]

I saw this the other day on TV also. I don't know why it would matter if a contestant had SRS. She has become a woman anatomically, so what's the real difference now. It's not like the contest has a strength or contact catagory. Beauty is beauty.

I don't think the pagent commitee or the GG contestants are afraid of a TS girl being unfairly beautiful. Let's face it, there are plenty of stunningly beautiful GG's in the world. No shortage at all.

This girl is definitely beautiful.

[Unisex]

No.....there's have been a few sports that are allowing Trans women to compete with genetic women so why not pageants.
Since there is no cosmetic surgery ban what unfair advantage does she really have??

She was on Fox news and they said that "enhancements" such as breast and buttocks were grounds for disqualification.

[DYNACORD]

She was on Fox news and they said that "enhancements" such as breast and buttocks were grounds for disqualification.

Now that's probably more like it. I was wondering if a contestant could have any kind of enhancements. I would think not.
So, if those are the rules, it pretty much leaves out most TS women.
Rules are rules.

[Indy24]

No.....there's have been a few sports that are allowing Trans women to compete with genetic women so why not pageants.
Since there is no cosmetic surgery ban what unfair advantage does she really have??

I was being sarcastic.

[Ms Remy M]

Just read an article this morning, she has been accepted back into the Pageant. However; it is under the condition that she can prove her legal documents 'classify' her as Female in Canada. Various provinces of Canada have different requirements for that wonderful 'F' on legal documents, but surely she has all that in order already and she get back in with no problems.

[GroobySteven]

Since there is no cosmetic surgery ban what unfair advantage does she really have??

Good point.